Hindustan Times says the film is visually extraordinary and highly imaginative, but its simple story becomes repetitive and does not fully match the strength of its images.

Koimoi says the film looks magnificent and creates a memorable mix of horror, fantasy and drama, helped greatly by its cinematography and background score.

News18 says Tumbbad has an original concept, striking visuals and a strong atmosphere, with its fresh mix of mythology and horror making it stand out.

Filmibeat says the film is visually stunning, imaginative and different, with strong performances, excellent design and an impressive use of mythology.

The Times of India says the film is genuinely scary and atmospheric, with excellent production design, cinematography and a clever story about human greed.

India TV News says Tumbbad is a fresh and imaginative horror fantasy with striking visuals, unusual mythology and a strong atmosphere that sets it apart from typical Hindi horror films.

India Today says the dark fairy tale stands out for its remarkable visuals, folklore and clear message about how greed can destroy people.

The Indian Express says the film is a beautiful and memorable morality tale, praising its striking look, strange mythology and Sohum Shah's committed performance.