Koimoi strongly criticizes Toaster, saying its dark comedy setup quickly turns bizarre, irritating, and unfunny. The review says Rajkummar Rao struggles with a weak role, Sanya Malhotra is wasted, and the film fails to deliver real entertainment.

HT calls the movie a madcap comedy, that starts with promise but loses steam later. The review says Rajkummar Rao’s eccentric performance, and Sanya Malhotra’s breezy presence keep the film engaging early on, especially as the plot spins from a miser wanting back a wedding-gift toaster into chaos and murder.

Bollywood Hungama gives Toaster 3/5, calling it a quirky entertainer with an unusual plot and a fun central performance by Rajkummar Rao. The review says the film works best in its comic, eccentric moments and gets support from actors like Sanya Malhotra, Seema Pahwa, Abhishek Banerjee and Farah Khan.