DNA India praises the film's audacious approach, Ranbir and Deepika's performances and exceptional chemistry, while noting inconsistent pacing in the second half.

Hindustan Times praises the performances, music and intriguing exploration of self discovery, though it finds parts of the narrative underdeveloped and slow.

Koimoi praises Ranbir and Deepika and the film's visual treatment, but feels Imtiaz Ali repeats familiar themes and delivers an ultimately predictable conclusion.

Bollywood Hungama praises the lead performances and chemistry but calls the film a major disappointment, criticizing its execution and limited audience appeal.

News18 praises Ranbir Kapoor and Deepika Padukone, but finds Tamasha inconsistent, shifting between inventive ideas and self indulgent storytelling.

Filmibeat praises the lead performances and the film's exploration of identity and self-discovery, calling it an engaging one-time watch despite its flaws.

TOI praises Ranbir and Deepika's convincing chemistry and emotional performances, but finds the journey long winded and boring in portions.

India TV says Tamasha offers a meaningful and rewarding experience, though its nonlinear storytelling can make the film difficult to follow.

India Today calls Tamasha an absorbing experience, strongly praising Ranbir, Deepika, the cinematography and music, despite some pacing problems.

The Indian Express praises Deepika and Ranbir and finds strong ideas in the second half, but feels the story repeatedly loses focus and eventually peters out.