India TV News says Vicky Kaushal brings Sam Manekshaw vividly to life through his distinctive gait, roaring voice, confidence and commanding attitude.

DNA India says Vicky Kaushal delivers an acting masterclass, but the random collection of anecdotes fails to do justice to Sam Manekshaw’s extraordinary life.

Filmibeat says Vicky Kaushal gives a career best performance and Fatima Sana Shaikh impresses, though the first half needed tighter writing.

BollywoodLife says Vicky Kaushal’s pitch perfect performance and Meghna Gulzar’s sincere treatment make the film an admirable and engaging tribute.

Hindustan Times says Vicky Kaushal powers several engaging individual episodes, but the disconnected structure and distracting music make the overall film forgettable.

Koimoi says Vicky Kaushal makes a committed effort, but confusing writing, weak character portrayals and routine direction squander the remarkable subject.

Pinkvilla says Vicky Kaushal gives an extraordinary performance, though the episodic structure and weaker second half limit the film’s impact.

Bollywood Hungama calls it a sincere and well intentioned biopic elevated by Vicky Kaushal, but lacking enough cinematic highs and emotional impact.

News18 says Vicky Kaushal gives one of his finest performances in a grand period drama that effectively blends patriotism, duty and determination.

NDTV praises Vicky Kaushal’s spirited performance and Meghna Gulzar’s restrained direction in an ambitious and emotionally rewarding biopic.