News18 praises the emotional pull, music and chemistry, while noting that the writing doesn’t always match the strength of the lead pair.

HT said the story is familiar and clichéd, but Ahaan-Aneet’s chemistry, soulful music and emotional sincerity give the film life.

Koimoi praised the newcomers, especially their screen presence, but strongly criticized the script, loopholes, melodrama, stretched climax and dated treatment.

Pinkvilla praised the chemistry, music, emotional depth and Mohit Suri’s direction; noted the storyline is familiar but still effective and polished.

Taran Adarsh called Saiyaara a captivating cinematic experience and praised its direction, heartfelt romance, chart topping music and strong lead performances.

Filmibeat described it as a heartwarming romantic drama with strong music, heartbreak and second chances; praised both debutants for making the love story work.

TOI called the movie visually lush, emotive and melody driven, with impressive leads and heartfelt romance, but best suited as a one-time watch for romantic musical fans.

India TV praised Ahaan and Aneet’s performances, but felt Mohit Suri’s love story did not fully land and was too heavy on sorrow with limited lighter moments.

India Today called the movie emotional, musical and entertaining despite visible flaws; praised Ahaan Panday’s screen presence and the film’s heartfelt romantic mood.

Indian Express found Ahaan Panday and Aneet Padda promising, but felt the love story was weighed down by inconsistent writing, heavy dialogue and dated melodrama.