DNA India says the film is emotionally thoughtful and surprisingly entertaining, with Akshay bringing dignity to Rustom and the changing perspectives keeping the familiar story interesting.

Hindustan Times says Akshay gives Rustom sharpness and charm, while the courtroom scenes remain engaging. Weak effects and the long runtime hurt an otherwise intriguing thriller.

Koimoi says Akshay and the entertaining murder mystery keep viewers interested, although Rustom is presented as too perfect and the film takes major liberties with the real case.

BollywoodLife says the film is not bad and Akshay performs strongly, but firmer writing and more convincing storytelling could have made it a much better courtroom drama.

Bollywood Hungama says the film is a well made crime thriller with enough captivating moments to entertain, even though some portions are loose.

News18 says Akshay and Pavan Malhotra are the main strengths, but the film simplifies the fascinating Nanavati case and turns its courtroom drama into a disappointing lost opportunity.

Filmibeat says the film has suspense, drama and a strong Akshay performance, but high expectations, weak execution and overdone commercial elements make it disappointing.

The Times of India says Akshay is the backbone of the film and gives an understated performance. The courtroom drama has flaws but remains engaging enough to watch.

India TV News says Akshay Kumar is the main strength of this crime thriller and carries much of the film.

India Today says Akshay is convincing, but predictable twists and the attempt to turn Rustom into a patriotic hero weaken what could have been a stronger crime thriller.