DNA India says the screenplay lacks energy, the Meghalaya track feels forced and the music is surprisingly weak for a film built around a band.

Hindustan Times says the band members still share convincing chemistry and the performances are strong. The film may lack a major conflict, but the friendship and music driven story remain engaging.

Koimoi says the film has a confused script, weak music and a slow pace, with nostalgia providing only a few enjoyable moments.

BollywoodLife says the cast performs well and the cinematography is attractive, but the story and music fail to recreate the charm of the original.

Bollywood Hungama says the film has a slow narrative, weak writing, forgettable music and little entertainment value.

News18 says the performances and Meghalaya scenery have some appeal, but the film lacks the fun, energy and memorable music of the original.

Filmibeat says the cast has some good moments, but the thin story, dull music and weak emotional connection make the reunion disappointing.

The Times of India says the performances, especially Farhan, Arjun and Purab, work well, but the confused screenplay and weak music stop the sequel from becoming truly engaging.

India TV News says the sequel stays true to the spirit of the original and continues Magik’s musical journey with sincerity. The performances, music and emotional connections make it a worthy follow-up.

India Today says the film looks beautiful in Meghalaya, but the story is slow, the characters are difficult to connect with and the music is disappointing.