DNA India felt PK falls short of 3 Idiots and the Munna Bhai films, but still praised the lead performances and considered it a must watch.

Hindustan Times praised Aamir Khan's performance, the humour and the film's bold social message. It found the second half slightly overdramatic but still called the film a winner and highly recommended it.

Koimoi praised the layered story, humour, emotions and social message, but felt the second half becomes slightly overdramatic and drags near the end.

Bollywood Hungama called it an outstanding entertainer with strong performances, an engaging story and enough humour and emotion to appeal to both mass and urban audiences.

Filmibeat praised the original concept, strong script, depth and Aamir Khan's performance, calling it an entertaining film with an important message.

The Times of India praised the film's bold ideas, humour, emotional appeal and performances, saying its unusual outsider viewpoint makes the social message effective.

India Today found the film entertaining, thoughtful and important for the questions it raises about religion and blind faith. It strongly praised Aamir Khan and the overall storytelling.

The Indian Express praised Aamir Khan's fresh performance and the engaging first half, but felt the film loses focus after the interval and becomes too sentimental and preachy.