DNA India praises Imtiaz Ali's bold direction, Alia Bhatt's outstanding performance and India's beautiful landscapes, calling the film a must-watch.

Hindustan Times praises Alia Bhatt's moving performance, soulful music and beautiful cinematography but finds the central relationship unconvincing.

Koimoi praises A. R. Rahman's music and beautiful cinematography but criticizes the weak screenplay, poor chemistry and predictable climax.

Bollywood Hungama praises Alia Bhatt's excellent performance and striking visuals but criticizes the treatment and limited mainstream appeal.

Filmibeat applauds the outstanding performances, beautiful locations and soulful music, calling the film a refreshing and emotional experience.

The Times of India praises Alia Bhatt's remarkable performance, bold storytelling and stunning visuals, despite some slow stretches.

It's a different Imtiaz Ali romance with few moments of joy but over the top it tests your patience.

India Today praises the cinematography and music but criticizes the slow pace, unrealistic character behaviour and weak storytelling.

The Indian Express praises the beautiful scenery but finds the story unconvincing, with Alia Bhatt struggling in some emotional scenes.