Filmibeat applauds Shahid Kapoor and Tabu's emotional performances, breathtaking cinematography and powerful climax, calling the film a moving cinematic experience.

DNA India praises Vishal Bhardwaj's masterful storytelling, powerful performances by Shahid Kapoor and Tabu, and haunting portrayal of Kashmir, despite minor flaws.

Hindustan Times praises Vishal Bhardwaj's bold direction, powerful performances, haunting music and realistic portrayal of Kashmir, calling the film a remarkable cinematic achievement.

Koimoi celebrates Bhardwaj's masterful adaptation, exceptional acting, powerful writing and beautiful cinematography, calling it a remarkable cinematic achievement.

Bollywood Hungama appreciates the talented cast and promising beginning but criticizes the slow screenplay, excessive length and disappointing second half.

The Times of India praises the brilliant adaptation, outstanding performances and striking Kashmir setting, despite some excessive music and lengthy scenes.

Vishal Bhardwaj, Bollywood's master of portraying Shakespeare's plays, ends the trilogy with Hamlet's screen adaptation ‘Haider'.

India Today applauds Shahid Kapoor and Tabu's performances, beautiful cinematography and complex relationships, although the film could have been shorter.

The Indian Express praises the stunning visuals and attention to detail but finds the storytelling fragmented, lengthy and emotionally unsatisfying.