DNA India says the individual performances and visuals work, but Aditya and Katrina lack convincing romantic chemistry. The rushed climax also needs more emotional depth.

Hindustan Times says Aditya Roy Kapur and Tabu impress and Kashmir looks beautiful, but the superficial romance, melodrama and loose screenplay make the adaptation disappointing.

Koimoi says the film looks magical and has impressive performances, but its slow pace, script gaps and weak second half leave the romance without enough impact.

BollywoodLife says the cinematography, music and performances have appeal, but the confused treatment, slow buildup and weak romance keep the film from reaching its potential.

Bollywood Hungama says outstanding cinematography cannot rescue a confusing screenplay, poor emotional connection and weak chemistry between the leads.

News18 says the film is not perfect, but its dreamy pace, attractive visuals and committed performances create a skillfully made and engaging romance.

Filmibeat says the film is flawed but visually captivating, with beautiful music, scenery and performances making the slow romantic drama worth watching.

The Times of India says the film looks gorgeous and Tabu shines, but style overwhelms substance. The central romance lacks the passion and depth needed to make the adaptation fully work.

India TV News says the film has beautiful visuals, lavish sets and soulful music, but the characters and story fail to deliver the grand romance the material promises.

India Today says Kashmir, the music and performances by Aditya Roy Kapur and Tabu are major strengths, but the story wanders and rushes important developments near the end.