DNA India calls it a well intentioned immigration drama that intermittently tugs at the heart but ultimately feels unfulfilled. Shah Rukh excels emotionally, while Vicky provides the standout performance.

India TV says Shah Rukh rules as the sincere Hardy, but Vicky Kaushal outshines everyone during his brief role. The emotional story works despite predictable portions.

Filmibeat finds the movie beautiful, elegant and suitable for family viewing, but not the expected “wow” collaboration. The performances and music compensate for ordinary writing.

BollywoodLife praises Hirani for reviving Shah Rukh’s romantic, emotionally expressive persona within a socially relevant immigration story. The film’s heart and performances receive the strongest approval.

Hindustan Times calls it a warm, family friendly tale packed with emotion, humour and nostalgia. Shah Rukh is the heart of the film, though his chemistry with Taapsee is inconsistent.

Koimoi says the promising immigration subject is weakened by a half baked, unconvincing screenplay. Shah Rukh fits Rajkumar’s world, while Vicky supplies the film’s strongest passage.

Pinkvilla calls it an emotional, patriotic and potentially enduring modern classic. Shah Rukh and Taapsee excel, although slow stretches and uneven jokes need trimming.

Bollywood Hungama praises the message, emotional passages and dependable performances. The film carries Rajkumar’s familiar stamp but uneven writing prevents it from matching his finest work.

News18 considers it a heartwarming Christmas entertainer and one of Shah Rukh’s most significant performances.

NDTV praises the solid screenplay, ethical questions and uniformly strong performances. Shah Rukh and Taapsee lead confidently, with Vicky memorable in his brief appearance.