DNA India says the friendship and performances feel real and mature, especially Anushka's work, but borrowed ideas and limited emotional impact weaken the film.

Hindustan Times says Ranbir and Anushka are excellent and the film looks beautiful, but the story is difficult to relate to and does not create enough sympathy for its characters.

Koimoi says the performances, music and emotional treatment of one-sided love make the film appealing, though it is slightly too long and uses some familiar cliches.

BollywoodLife says the film has some lovely moments and Ranbir works well, but the weak second half stops the romance from reaching its full potential.

Bollywood Hungama says the film is a polished Diwali entertainer with rich visuals, hit music, an engaging screenplay and a modern approach to relationships.

News18 says the lead performances make the emotional drama work, especially Ranbir, who makes Ayan's heartbreak convincing.

Filmibeat says Ranbir, Anushka, the dialogue, music and glossy presentation make the film enjoyable, although the final twist feels forced and disconnected.

The Times of India says the film is beautiful, emotionally mature and well acted. Its romantic conflicts feel more thoughtful than Karan Johar's earlier films.

India TV News says the film explores the passion of love and the comfort of friendship, with the relationships and performances giving the romantic drama its appeal.

India Today says Ranbir and Anushka give strong performances, but the film relies too heavily on familiar Bollywood romance, references and melodrama.