Subhash K. Jha speaks about Ek Vivaah Aisa Bhi

By Subhash K. Jha, Bollywood Hungama News Network

Nobility as a quality in cinema seems almost the hallmark of Sooraj Barjatya's cinema. Especially during these times of stress, cynicism and violence, any film that doesn't belch out venomous fumes is worthy of applause.

But wait. Before we cheer Ek Vivaah Aisa Bhi for walking the straight and narrow road, let's be warned. The route taken by the narration looks like a poor, tame, tepid and technically shoddy facsimile of Anil Ganguly's Tapasya (which was produced by Barjatya) and more recently, the Barjatya-directed Vivaah which won extra points for its elegant and fluent simplicity of narration.

Director Kaushuk Ghatak takes us through Barjatya's joint-family system. Yes, even the infamous gaajar ka halwa makes its mouth-watering appearance somewhere at the start during the first wedding that rolls our well-'read' Barjatya carpet at the start.

Yup, the film begins and ends with elaborate weddings replete with the whole cast plus sundry junior artistes dressed in garish pinks, mauves and greens prancing to the sound of festivities.

But somewhere this prolonged music-video 'Vivaah' lacks the graceful zing of the other Shahid Kapoor-Amrita Rao film, released two years ago, which had enough meals and morning walks to make our digestive system feel balanced- out.

Ek Vivaah.... is lopsided in its fervent festivity. The first-half where a romance grows between two small-town singers Sonu Sood and Eesha Koppikhar groans and creaks with monotonous semi-classical songs.

The music (Ravindra Jain) is simply awful. Jain had done the songs and music in the original film Tapasya. One still remembers Kishore Kumar's theme song 'Jo Raah Chuni Tuney' with goosebumpy affection.

The songs and music in Ek Vivaah Aisa Bhi are dreadfully dull. The film gets by on the strength of Bengali litterateur Ashapurna Devi's powerful story of a self-willed woman who sacrifices marriage to look after her siblings.

Parts of the second-half capture the emotional aroma of the original story. Especially effective is the relationship between the spinster and her devoted soul mate who refuses to marry any other girl. Suchitra Sen and Ashok Kumar shared a similar platonic rapport in Asit Sen's Mamta. And so did Raakhee Gulzar and Parikshat Sahni in Tapasya. They had the spirit.

Eesha Koppikhar and Sonu Sood are sincere. But they lack the gravity and ingrained wisdom and dignity required to portray lives that go beyond self-interest.

What works for this Vivaah is its intrinsic integrity. At a time when everyone is making films that either go for the guffaw or head for the libido, here's a film that tackles very basic traditional values and the feelings underlining the colourful festivities related to the Hindu wedding. The language is often so old fashioned that it borders on the archaic.

But at least nobody is acting over-smart.

ekvivaahaisabhi3.jpg

Box Office Results

  1. Pizza INR 1.71 cr.
  2. Hate Story 2 INR 5.41 cr.
  3. H.. Sharma Ki Dulhania INR 57 cr.
  4. Lekar Hum Deewana Dil INR 2.4 cr.
  5. Bobby Jasoos INR 11.6 cr.

Movie Reviews