Movie Review: Shikhar ...

By Subhash K. Jha, Indo-Asian News Service

alt="image" />Film: "Shikhar"; Starring Ajay Devgan, Shahid Kapoor, Bipasha Basu, Amrita

Rao, Jawed Shaikh, Sushant Singh, Farah; Directed by John Matthew Matthan; Rating:***

It's the easiest thing in the world to get cynical about a film that embraces idealism

and a vision of corruption-less India.

Like Ashutosh Gowariker's "Swades", which came exactly a year ago, "Shikhar" attempts to

look at life in the rural hinterland as idealistic, unspoilt and desirable. The city folks

represented by an utterly materialistic Ajay Devgan air-drop into this world of looming

idealism to bung a spanner in the works.

Still the film works...and how! It peels away layers of our saturated sensibilities to

give us the glimpse of a world where principles of beauty and innocence still reign

supreme.

Into this ecological arcadia comes the ruthless builder with his obscene designs and

vulgar vision. GG (Ajay Devgan) wants to turn Guruji's (Jawed Shaikh) utopia into a concrete

jungle. "Just like Las Vegas," he dreams away, with his girl Natasha (Bipasha Basu) being a

nubile spectator.

The two set off to seduce Guruji's impressionable son Jai (Shahid Kapoor). And herein

lies Matthan's main masterstroke in this film about the end of innocence. Shahid as the

boy-man lured into a world of decadent materialism strikes such rich chords of believability

into his character that you are one with the director's vision of corrupted idealism.

Matthan's screenplay, co-written with Abbas Tyrewallah, has enough sustenance and force

to make the spirit of idealism shorn of wide-eyed innocence. Portions of the film (for

example the distraught Jai looking for his father in the forest or the contrived,

crowd-fuelled climax) are almost mythological in their melodramatic velocity.

But the narration holds together, thanks to the lucid sub-text and a high level of

professionalism applied to the telling of the idealistic story.

The characters are plot-driven all the way, so that it becomes easier for the director to

manoeuvre them through a limpid labyrinth of pulls and pushes effectively worked into the

narration.

The director doesn't delve into too many moral or physical details of the two worlds that

the protagonists inhabit. Shahid's character goes swiftly and fluently from innocence to

worldly wisdom. The speech patterns change and so does the slur of his sensitivities as his

orphaned companion (Amrita Rao, sweet and competent) helplessly watches her sweetheart turn

into a sweat-heart.

The scenes between Jai and his machiavellian mentor Devgan lack a certain dynamism. But

Matthan makes up for that loss by focusing on the dynamics of degeneration that drive Jai

away from his father.

The sharply drawn interludes in Singapore where Shahid busies himself with his new,

trendy friends (Devgan and Bipasha), neglecting and belittling his old friends from his

Utopian universe, and the morality-defining scenes where Jai tries to question GG's values

(for example his mild objection to the word 'sexy') qualify the film's ambitious vision,

using an economy of expression and an intuitive understanding of the mechanics of modern

morality.

Most of all, Matthan's film is a well-pitched morality tale. Its ramrod-straight

ideological underbelly comes alive in sharp strokes of leisurely expressions, which do not

preclude a celebration of cinematic values from its principled purview.

Like Guru Dutt's "Pyasa", Hrishikesh Mukherjee's "Satyakam", Goldie Behl's "Bas Itna Sa

Khwab Hai" and Gowariker's "Swades", "Shikhar" is a valid cinematic documentation of

ideological annihilation.

A.K. Bir's cinematography enhances the tonal textures of the mutating mores. But this

guileless film isn't about technique. It's about the heart, and how to open it to feelings

and moods that we thought were gone with the morality-driven filmmakers like Guru Dutt and

Hrishikesh Mukherjee.

It's no coincidence that Shahid often reminds us of Raj Kapoor in "Shree 420". He gets

surprisingly strong support from one of Bollywood's most powerful character actors, Sushant

Singh.

The film marks a notable return to grassroots morality. Matthan's idealism is

predominantly Nehruvian. The builders and politicians of independent India have had a field

day at our expense. Is it payback time now? Shikhar suggests it might be.

Naïve or conscientious? The choice is entirely ours.

Bollywood.com Rating: 2